Food Pantries in Bayville, NY 3 locations Find food pantries, check hours, and reserve visits — all in one app. Get the Plentiful App The Village Church The Village Church 9 Mountain Ave., Bayville, NY 11560 (516) 628-2737 St. Gertrude's Food Pantry St. Gertrude's 28 School St., Bayville, NY 11709 1931 St. Gertrudes St. Gertrudes 28 School St, Bayville, NY 11560